Breathe poster

Breathe movie poster

For her sophomore directing effort, the French actress Mélanie Laurent (Inglorious Basterds, Enemy) explores once again relationships between women, this time focusing on a couple teenage girls.

Charlie (Joséphine Japy) is a studious and introverted 17-year old girl raised in a broken home. While she seems to see her young mother (Isabelle Carré – Romantics Anonymous, Beautiful Memories) almost as an older sister, she doesn’t care much for her – mostly absent and cheating – father.  Unknowingly having an emotional void to fill, she throws herself almost instantly into a passionate friendship with Sarah (Lou de Laâge), a charismatic and wild new student. Of course, everything seems too good to be true and their relationship slowly but surely turns toxic.

The first half of the movie is without a doubt the most solid part. Advancing slowly and giving us some beautiful, almost contemplative sequences, Breathe does a fine job at showcasing onscreen how Charlie feels inside. Starting on a somewhat melancholic note, the movie changes tone with the arrival of Sarah, suddenly becoming gleeful and carefree. As soon as Charlie starts doubting her friend, we however get transported to a different kind of film, one ruled by cruelty, bullying and leading to an irremediable fate.

I must admit that Ms. Laurent shows great skills at making us experience the life of an 18-year old, more particularly when it comes to showcasing her characters’ inner turmoils and joys. She also pays a surprising attention to visuals and atmosphere – I’m suspecting she might have looked closely at Mr. Tarantino’s meticulous directing style – telling us she aims at becoming a serious filmmaker. As for the lead actresses, they deliver strong performances – including Ms. Carré playing against type  – carrying the movie through its rocky emotional journey.

There are however a few things that bother me here, starting with the fact that Breathe seems haunted by the success of Blue is the Warmest Color. Not only the relationships are similar – this one being platonic – but Sarah looks like a negative of Adèle both characters having similar traits. Ms. de Laâge also has a Béatrice Dalle (Bettie Blue) – je ne sais quoi – feel which makes you easily anticipate where her character is going. I also thought the second half wasn’t as convincing as the first one. I know Ms.  Laurent claims Larry Clark (Kids, Ken Park) as one of her influences but in Mr. Clark’s work despair is always creeping, thus leading to a logic conclusion, while here the changes in tones are too abrupt, making the ending not that credible – and the fact that Charlie is like her mom underlines this.

A solid but not fully convincing work, Breathe mostly positions Ms. Laurent as a promising female-centric filmmaker.

Director: Mélanie Laurent – Actors: Joséphine Japy, Lou de Laâge Dominguez – Running Time: 1:31 – Year: 2015 – Country: France
Click here to watch the Breathe trailer
The following two tabs change content below.
Fred Thom

Fred Thom

Editor-in-Chief/Founder/Film Critic at Plume Noire
The founder and editor-in-chief of Plume Noire, Fred Thom covers film festivals and writes movie reviews. He was born in Marseilles, France and is now living in Los Angeles, California.
Fred Thom

Latest posts by Fred Thom (see all)